Author: Princess

  • An overview of New Decree 33 of 2020 regarding the Special Judicial Committee for Incomplete and Canceled Real Estate Projects in the Emirate of Dubai

    An overview of New Decree 33 of 2020 regarding the Special Judicial Committee for Incomplete and Canceled Real Estate Projects in the Emirate of Dubai

    By Mohamed Ghanem
    Lawyer I LLM I Lecturer I Speaker I DIAC Arbitrator
    December 9, 2020

    Acquisition of distressed real estate projects in the Emirate of Dubai between the practice and the legal legislation. An overview of New Decree 33 of 2020 regarding the Special Judicial Committee for Incomplete and Canceled Real Estate Projects in the Emirate of Dubai.

    The practical experience of implementing Decree No. 21 of 2013 in regard of forming a special judicial committee to liquidate the canceled projects in the Emirate of Dubai has revealed the urgent need for legislation to regulate the acquisition of the canceled real estate project, which is of course a stalled and incomplete project, the distress project’s acquisition is usually takes place by a new developer or the existing project contractor who has Financial capabilities to complete the project in cases where liquidation of the project has no economic viability for the investors and the banks financing the project.

    The practical practices of the judicial committees have faced challenges in cases where the completion of the project has better results for the investors and the banks financing the project rather than the project liquidation. The main challenge was absence of private legislation regulation the project acquisition.

    On the other hand, the Real Estate Regulatory Agency has spared no effort in receiving offers to acquire stalled real estate projects, and in mediating to find friendly solutions with the former developer who was unable to complete the project. The main obstacle was the lack of legislation that would give the Agency or any other judicial body the authority to transfer the project to a new developer in the absence of an agreement with the old developer or in cases of inability to contact with the old developer. In the midst of these challenges, the urgent need for legislation to regulate all aspects of the acquisition of the real estate project emerged.

    Decree 33 of 2020 regarding the Special Judicial Committee for Incomplete and Canceled Real Estate Projects in the Emirate of Dubai is a new start and laid the groundwork for legislation regulating the acquisition of a real estate project in the Emirate of Dubai.

    The decree defined the incomplete real estate project as the real estate project that was directly built, but stopped for reasons related to the real estate developer or buyer, or for any other reason.

    The jurisdiction of the Judicial Committee entrusted with incomplete and canceled real estate projects in the Emirate of Dubai according to Article 6 of the new decree did not differ radically from its jurisdiction under Decree No. 21 of 2013, except with regard to Paragraph A / 6, which decided that the jurisdiction of the Judicial Committee is to define the rights and duties of each real estate developer from which the incomplete real estate project was transferred and the real estate developer who will undertake the re-completion of the unfinished real estate project.

    This particular part will allow the committees to set mechanisms and controls for the rights and obligations of the former developer and the new developer with regard to the rights of investors and buyers associated with the project, and we hope that these controls include answering questions that have long been circulating in the minds of investors and buyers in stalled projects, including whether the new developer adheres to the delivery date in the old developer contracts? Does he abide by the terms of compensation for the delay? Does he adhere to the schedule of payments? In addition to the problems of fictitious registration of some units in the initial real estate registry with the names of buyers who did not pay any amounts, and the problems of receiving amounts outside the escrow accounts for projects.

    On the other hand, the decree organized a mechanism for cooperation between the Judicial Committee and the Real Estate Regulatory Agency as a technical body with long-standing experience in real estate regulation, through which it could provide data, information and proposed solutions to deal with the incomplete real estate projects. Rather, the decree delegated the agency and gave it the authority to withdraw the real estate projects from the Judicial Committee to re-study them and indicate the possibility of their re-completion or settlement of associated disputes.

    With this balance between the role of the Judicial Committee and the Real Estate Regulatory Agency, the legislator hopes to find practical and legal solutions to the problem of the acquisition of stalled real estate projects in a way that ensures achieving the best results for the benefit of investors and buyers in the interest of real estate investment in the Emirate of Dubai.

    The decree did well, as it canceled any text in any other legislation to the extent that it contradicts the provisions of this decree, in order to free the judicial committees to find practical solutions that are not broken by legislative obstacles in other laws.

  • Dubai Courts Judgment Accepted Bankruptcy Procedures for Sharjah Free zone-based company

    Dubai Courts Judgment Accepted Bankruptcy Procedures for Sharjah Free zone-based company

    By Mohamed Ghanem
    Lawyer I LLM I Lecturer I Speaker I DIAC Arbitrator
    February 7, 2023

    In a judicial precedent, the Dubai courts issued its ruling to open bankruptcy procedures for a company in the free zone in Sharjah and its owner, despite the fact that the Public Prosecution recommended that the Dubai courts not have jurisdiction to hear the case, given that the debtor’s headquarters is in the Emirate of Sharjah.

    The court supported the defence of the company seeking bankruptcy “creditor” regarding the exceptional jurisdiction in bankruptcy cases in the event that the merchant retired from trade, as stipulated in Article 35 of the Federal Civil Procedure Law, then the lawsuit can be filed before the court of which the domicile of the defendant belongs, in contrary to the general jurisdiction in bankruptcy cases, “the domicile court The trader” and that after it was proven from the documents submitted and the defence that the commercial license of the company whose bankruptcy is required is expired, and the ruling was adopted that not to renew the license as evidence of the retirement of trade and that its owner resides in the Emirate of Dubai, and from there the jurisdiction is held to consider the request to open bankruptcy procedures to the court of the domicile of the defendant according to the aforementioned exceptional jurisdiction .

  • DUBAI LEGISLATIONS: Inspecting validity of the procedures of Deregistration in the Interim Real Estate Register “UnilateralTermination”

    DUBAI LEGISLATIONS: Inspecting validity of the procedures of Deregistration in the Interim Real Estate Register “UnilateralTermination”

    By Mohamed Ghanem
    Lawyer I LLM I Lecturer I Speaker I DIAC Arbitrator
    November 21, 2017

    DUBAI LEGISLATIONS: Inspecting validity of the procedures of #Deregistration in the Interim Real Estate Register “#UnilateralTermination” in the light of the provisions of Law No. (19) of 2017 Amending Law No. (13) of 2008 on the Interim Real Estate Register in the Emirate of #Dubai.

    In the light of the legislative leadership of the Emirate of #Dubai in the real estate sector, Law No. (19) of 2017 Amending Certain Provisions of Law No. (13) of 2008 on the Interim Real Estate Register in the Emirate of #Dubai was issued. Such Law has resolved a judicial, jurisprudential and legislative controversy that has lasted for many years since the issuance of Law No. (13) of w998 and its amendment by Law No. (9) of 2009 on the legality of the procedures of #Deregistration of units with the Land Department.

    At that time, the judiciary and jurisprudence adopted two different approaches. The approach which was adopted by the majority and supported by court rulings provided that the cancellation/deregistration procedures represent a unilateral termination of the contract, which requires that the developer refunds the paid funds to the #Investor. This is on the basis that termination, in accordance with the provisions of Article (267) of the Federal Civil Transactions Law, is either consensual or judicial. In addition, the role of the Land Department, when a dispute arises between the developer and the buyer, is generally limited to #Reconciliation endeavours and proposal of appropriate solutions with the aim of reaching an amicable settlement without expansion of such role to include deciding on the merits of the dispute by termination or performance of the contract. This means that the Land Department is an administrative body not a judicial body and the cancellation decisions it issues represent a mere proposal or recommendation and administrative decisions that do not have any binding res judicata before courts. Such decisions do not preclude resubmission of the #Dispute by either party to the competent court for consideration of the termination of the #Contract. In addition, such approach provided that in case of unilateral termination of a sale contract and resale of the unit, the developer shall restitute all the funds to the investor for termination of the contract for impossibility of performance. The reason therefor is that in the case of resale of the unit, the first buyer will not be able to avoid termination by payment of the price, as the unit has been already sold to a new investor.

    The second approach and its supporters, mostly those defending the rights of real estate developers, provided that cancellation of registration is not unilateral termination. Such approach considered the said cancellation as a mere utilization of the right to termination legally prescribed under the provisions of Article (11) of Law No. (13) of 2008 Regulating Interim Real Estate Register in the Emirate of Dubai, as amended. Such approach has mentioned the method of implementing the procedures included in the aforementioned Article in case that the buyer has breached his contractual obligations relevant to the instalments payable by him. In addition, such approach has entitled, the developer or other sellers of the units subject-matter of contracts, to sell such units in public auction in order to collect the remaining amounts payable by buyers. Such approach has also entitled the said parties to keep all the funds paid to them or deduct the percentages, set out in the said Article, from the value of such units and terminate the contract pursuant to the developer’s percentage of completion of the project. This approach also provided that such right was given by the legislator to the developer unrestricted or unconditional to being claimed before the courts. And thus, the decision of the Land Department on cancellation of registration merely decides termination and does not cause it and that the developer may not be criticized for keeping the said legal percentages as compensation, if the registration cancellation procedures were valid.

    The legislative amendment under Law No. (19) of 2017 has resolved the dispute between both approaches. Such amendment stipulated that the developer shall be entitled, if the buyer has failed to pay the price, to cancel registration without the need to recourse to courts or arbitration, provided that the developer shall follow the cancellation procedures in the manner stipulated in the amendment. Thus, the legislative amendment has adopted a fair and middle position between both approaches. Such amendment explicitly stipulated that the Land Department’s cancellation of registration is a unilateral termination. In addition, such amendment has legalized such termination and made it a legal termination, i.e. termination under a legal text, which is a victory for the supporters of the second approach. However, it is worth noting that the legislative amendment has identified the cancellation procedures as public order and provided that failure to commit with such procedures shall render cancellation as null and void, which is a victory for the supporters of the first approach. In the end, the purpose of this legislative amendment is striking a balance between the interests of real estate developers and investors by providing for guarantees for both parties. And thus, there should be neither harm nor malice. Immunization is only assigned to the procedures carried out in the correct legal manner. In addition, the investor was not deprived, under an explicit provision, of resorting to courts or arbitration, in case that the developer abused the prescribed right.

    In conclusion, in the light of this new legislative amendment, the approach of courts will certainly be changed by adoption of the cancellation decisions issued by the Land Department in case that their procedures were valid. In case of invalidity, i.e. nullity, of such procedures, the courts will retain their jurisdiction in deciding the developer’s entitlement to requesting termination of the contract. In this case (nullity of procedures), the res judicata, under the judgments of the Court of Cassation in respect of termination of the contract for impossibility of performance, remains intact.

  • TERMINATION OF SALE AND PURCHASE AGREEMENT “SPA” UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF LAW # 13 FOR THE YEAR 2008, AS AMENDED BY LAW # 9 FOR THE YEAR 2009

    TERMINATION OF SALE AND PURCHASE AGREEMENT “SPA” UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF LAW # 13 FOR THE YEAR 2008, AS AMENDED BY LAW # 9 FOR THE YEAR 2009

    By Mohamed Ghanem
    Lawyer I LLM I Lecturer I Speaker I DIAC Arbitrator
    August 14, 2016

    The Legislator by promulgating the Real Estate laws in the Emirate of Dubai, specifically Law # 13 for the year 2008 with respect to registration of property in Dubai, as amended by Law # 9 for the year 2009 and the Executive Regulations # 6 for the year 2010, was intending to make balancing between the rights of the Developer and the Investor in the United Arab Emirates in order to secure the interests of both Parties and the community in general. The vision of the Legislator is clear that adequate guarantees were laid down to preclude a grievance and injustice and endeavors to achieve justice and equity. Article – 3 of the said law nullified any disposition of the off-plan sold Units when such disposition is not registered with the Interim Real Estate Register. Articles – 4 & 10 invalidates such disposition if it takes place before obtaining necessary approvals. This is in order to protect the interests of Investor, in addition to the penalties prescribed in the event that the amounts of money were not deposited in the Escrow Account in pursuance to the provisions of Law # 8 for the year 2007 with respect to Escrow Accounts leaving the funds of Investors under disposition of the Trustee of Escrow Account. All these measures are aimed for protection of the rights of Investor.

    On the other hand, the Developer is an Investor as well who employs thousands of persons and contributes in the economy of the Country and thereby be entitled to be secured. Hence the Legislator was very keen to secure its rights as did with the individual Investor. Article – 11 of Law # 13 for the year 2008, amended by Law # 9 for the year 2009, and Article – 15 of the Executive Regulations vide # 6 for the year 2010 regulated a situation whereby the Developer would be between the rock and hard. When the Investor defaults in payment and thus hinders and negatively affects the process of construction works and completion of the Project. At the same time the Developer may not be able to re-sell the Unit being registered in the name of Investors at the Interim Real Estate Register. Therefore the Legislator gave the Developer the right to terminate the Contract and retain the proportions prescribed by Article -11 referred to herein above.

    In the light of this comprehensive perspective it has appeared to the Legislator that the Real Estate Projects in the United Arab Emirates is a huge Project which requires a lot of money and that the Developer has sustained damages which affects its personal interest and the interests of community, in general as a result of suspension of construction works and non-completion of the Project due to default in payment by the Investors. Regulations and procedures were laid down in order to secure compensation for damages. The Land Department has been authorized to assume such procedures as being a neutral party. Hence Article – 11 of Law # 13 for the year 2008 and its amendments has included penalties for the default by the Buyer in settlement of the price which is the right of the Developer to terminate the Contract and to retain the proportions referred to in this Article as compensation for the damage sustained by the Developer provided that the procedures for notification shall be followed in the manner mentioned in the same Article under supervision and monitoring of the Land Department.

    As it is established within the interpretation rules, the special provision restricting the general provision, Article – 11 of Law # 13 for the year 2008 and its amendments is a special provision of the rules of the general doctrine for termination and does not contradict therewith in respect of retaining of a proportion of the amounts paid by the Investor as compensation. The general doctrine asserts termination by mutual agreement as well as the right of the Judge to order for termination and indemnity. From the practical perspective, the rulings of the Court of Cassation, Dubai repeatedly decided that the Order issued by the Land Department terminating sale of a Real Estate Unit and giving the Developer the right of retention of the proportions referred to in Article – 11 is a recommendation and administrative order which is not binding to the Courts and that only the Courts shall have jurisdiction to terminate the Contracts. In a recent Judgement, the Court of Cassation decided that termination of Contract by the Developer through the Land Department and re-sale of the Unit to a new Investor is a termination to be made by one of the Contracting Party and in such an event the Developer shall be liable to refund all amounts paid by the first Investor along with legal interest due to impossibility of performance of the Contract, because the Developer by re-sale of the Unit would have deprived the Investor to evade termination by way of payment at any time before the final Judgement, and that the Developer must before re-sale resort to the Court to prove the default of Investor and obtain Judgement for termination of the Contract.

  • Court of Cassation reconfirms that Developer’s Escrow Accounts can not be sized and it a legal safeguard, designed to protect buyers funds

    Court of Cassation reconfirms that Developer’s Escrow Accounts can not be sized and it a legal safeguard, designed to protect buyers funds

    By Mohamed Ghanem
    Lawyer I LLM I Lecturer I Speaker I DIAC Arbitrator
    October 17, 2024

    Court of Cassation reconfirms that Developer’s Escrow Accounts can not be sized and it a legal safeguard, designed to protect buyers and ensure the funds are used solely for the development of the real estate project.

    Dubai Land Department IEREI. AE Court of Cassation

    In a recent ruling by the General Authority of the Court of Cassation, a critical interpretation of Article 9 of Law No. 8 of 2007 concerning real estate development escrow accounts in Dubai was delivered, addressing the inviolability of these accounts in the context of developer creditors.

    The case originated when the Technical Office of the Court of Cassation sought the General Authority’s guidance on whether creditors of a real estate developer could seize funds deposited in escrow accounts established under Article 9. These accounts are a legal safeguard, designed to protect buyers and ensure the funds are used solely for the development of the real estate project.

    The General Authority, after thorough deliberation, concluded that the law explicitly prohibits any form of seizure—whether precautionary or executionary—of funds held in escrow for real estate development purposes. Article 9 mandates that these accounts are opened in the name of the project and are to be used exclusively for its construction. Even if a developer undertakes multiple projects, each project must have its own independent escrow account.

    The funds in these accounts, often collected from buyers purchasing off-plan units or from financiers of the project, are tightly regulated. The release of funds to the developer is allowed only in accordance with pre-determined stages of project completion, as specified in the sales contracts. This structure is intended to protect the rights of buyers and ensure the proper use of funds throughout the construction process.

    Crucially, the General Authority underscored that even creditors who are depositors or financiers of the project cannot seize the funds in the escrow account, irrespective of the type of debt or any judicial ruling supporting their claim. The only permissible disbursements from these accounts are payments related to the project, such as to contractors, consultants, and for marketing expenses.

    The ruling further clarified that this protection remains intact even if the name of the escrow account changes, as long as the funds were initially deposited in accordance with Article 9 of Law No. 8 of 2007. Consequently, if a creditor requests the court to impose a seizure on an escrow account, the court must ensure that the funds are not derived from buyers or project financiers and reject such requests.

    In conclusion, the General Authority firmly ruled that escrow accounts for real estate projects in Dubai, established under Article 9, are legally protected from any form of seizure for the benefit of a developer’s creditors. This decision reinforces the legislator’s intent to safeguard the rights of buyers and ensure the funds are used exclusively for the completion of real estate projects, regardless of the nature or legal basis of any claims made by the developer’s creditors.